A Biblical Christmas

Evangelical Christians claim that they believe the Bible is true.  They claim that what it says is important and relevant to their lives.  Because of this, they claim that they strive to live according to the truths found in Scripture.

Unfortunately, though, many of us are a little ignorant when it comes to knowing what the Bible actually says.

This is really a shame–especially for those who have been Christians for years and have been going to church/listening to sermons/reading the Bible for any length of time.

One of the easiest ways to see this is to examine what people think about the Christmas Story compared to what is actually in the Bible.  Many believers have a lot of non-biblical thoughts about what transpired at Jesus’ birth because of the inaccuracies found in Nativity scenes, Christmas plays, and even Christmas Carols.

Here are a few of the inaccuracies (in no particular order) that many people believe are found in the Bible, but are not.  I will include the Scripture references when appropriate and welcome any additional inaccuracies or questions.

1.  Mary rode on a donkey to Bethlehem. Sorry, but there is nothing in Scripture that states Mary rode a donkey or anything else to Bethlehem.  This is a small issue, but it aggravates me for some strange reason.

2.  The Innkeeper told Mary and Joseph that there was no room in the inn.  Wrong.  Luke 2:7 states that Mary and Joseph laid Jesus in a manger “because there was no room for them in the inn.”  There is no mention of who told them this.  Strangley, many of the Christmas plays I have seen even have the innkeeper’s wife getting into the act.  Sheesh.

3.  Mary gave birth in a stable.  Nothing in Scripture states this.  Again, Luke 2:7 states that Jesus was laid in a manger, but it does not say anything about a stable.  Some people assume this since a manger is a feed trough for “farm animals”, but there is no Biblical evidence for this assumption.  Others have stated that it could have been in a cave of some sort since caves were use by many people of that time as stables.  Really, though, the manger could have been anywhere.    

4.  There were animals present at the brith of Jesus.  No evidence for this either.  Sorry, animal lovers.

5.  The baby Jesus went to “sleep on the hay.”  Luke 2:7 said that he was wrapped in swaddling clothes and laid in a manger–no mention of hay. 

6.  The Angels sang to the shepherds about the birth of Jesus.  No Biblical support for this.  First, the Angel of the Lord appears.  Luke 2:10 states: “And the angel said unto them” and Luke 2:13 states: “And suddenly there was with the angel a multitude of the heavenly host praising God, and saying.”  Said and saying, not sang and singing.

7.  The star was present above Jesus the night of His birth.  This is a tough one, but there is no Scriptural reference for it.  Look at Luke 2:1-20–there is no mention of a star.  When the angel tells the shepherds about the sign of Jesus’ birth, he says “And this shall be a sign unto you; Ye shall find the babe wrapped in swaddling clothes, lying in a manger. (v. 12)”  They were not told to look for a bright star, but to look for a baby in a manger wrapped in swaddling clothes.  Matthew chapter 2 is where we first see a mention of a star.  In Matthew 2:2 the wise mens states that they “have seen the star in the east.”  Does this mean that they saw the star while the star was in the east (where they were from) or that they could see it from where they were from?  Good question that I don’t know the answer to.  However, Matthew 2:9 says that when they left Jerusalem and headed toward Bethlehem that “the star, which they saw in the east, went before them, till it came and stood over where the young child was.”  The star was not stationary over Jesus, but moved ahead of the wise men, leading them to Jesus until it finally stood over him.

8.  There were three wise men.  Inaccurate.  The wise men brough three gifts, but it does not say that there were only three men.  It could have been many more.

9.  The three wise men were present at the birth of Jesus.  Not so.  Matthew 2:9 and Matthew 2:11 both talk of “the young child,” not a newborn baby.  Also, Matthew 2:11 says that the young child was in a house. 

Some of these inaccuracies (like the Jesus being born in a stable or the innkeeper telling Mary and Joseph about the lack of room in the inn) may have indeed happened.  But, these things are not in the Bible.

There are more inaccuracies out there, of course.  However, with this short list you can probably see that many Christians are a little messed up when it comes to one of the most important parts of the Bible.  This may seem a little trivial to you (and it may indeed be), however it shows that some of us who follow Jesus may not be a Biblically literate as we should be.

The remedy for this is for us to see how privileged we are to have Bibles and actually study them instead of leaving them on a shelf until Sunday morning. 

Get your Bible out and read the Christmas story for youself.  You can find it in the first and second chapters of Matthew and Luke.  You may just see things there that you’ve seen before for the first time–if you know what I mean.


5 thoughts on “A Biblical Christmas

  1. This was an awesome blog. You can find out many of these things using Bible Software. You are already on the computer so why not study there. Also if you are the writer of this blog or if you write a blog yourself I would encourage you to check out href=”http://www.logos.com/reftagger”>Reftagger It is a great way to get these verses on your blog to be instantly read.

    Full disclosure: I work for Logos Bible Software so I am a little prejudiced…

    If you want to take your Bible study to the next level, take a look and give me a call and I would love to offer you a discounted price!

    Jared Bryant (800) 875-6467 ext 2319

  2. I think, in response to point number 7, regarding the star, you should check out a DVD entitled “Star of Bethlehem.” It is rather interesting, and eye opening.

  3. I am so grateful for your input. As the Bible story was being taught this morning in church, the preacher mentioned Mary on the donkey, I could see no mention of a donkey, and decided to really search the scriptures when I reached home, also see if I could find the reference on the www net. Much to my surprise there is no mention anywhere of Mary on a donkey. The THREE wisemen information was something with which I was familiar, Jesus “asleep” in the hay – that was news! “The cattle are lowing” as you say – no mention of cattle, once again – News! The stable? Again no mention of a stable. You have taught me quite a lot today and I thank you for this.
    I have often noticed things in Scripture which I have never noticed before, or teaching – maybe just one word – which is not correct. Keep up the good work, The Truth is so important. The song we were taught when very young, and children still are taught this, “Away in a Manger” lots of error there.

    • A lot of the items not found in the Bible have probably been added for dramatic effect in plays, movies, and music. It is not that some of those things were absolutely not present, it is that they are not in the Bible. Is it bad to imagine how things may have been? I don’t think so. But we need to be careful not to allow this type of thing to overshadow the fact that Jesus entered into this world, lived sinlessly, died on the cross, and rose again. Thanks for your comment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s